?

Log in

No account? Create an account
 
 
17 April 2006 @ 07:08 pm
Worst. Click trap. Ever.  
So I've been very busy researching interior design stuffs. I would like to put up my ideas and tentative plans in the near future...but first...I found an e-commerce site that chafed my ass enough for me to write a complaint to their feedback email. I've been looking for high-quality sofas, and I found a site with a great warranty, skilled crafters, etc. Sounds good, right?

Well, I habitually middle-clicked on a couch to view it in a new tab. (Bluetooth has been sketchy for me for ages. It finally pissed me off enough to plug in a third-party USB keyboard and mouse. This mouse has the standard assortment of buttons.) And I got a "no u cant save our pictuers!111!" alert that would. Not. Die. I had to quit Firefox to get it to go away.

What the hell, people?

So their feedback department got a love note from yours truly:

I'm running Firefox 1.5 on Mac OS X 10.3 (Panther), and I use a third-party USB mouse with a click wheel. I habitually middle-click website links to open them in new tabs. When I middle-clicked a couch on your website, I got an alert about not being permitted to save images from the site. As I will explain, middle and right click-trapping alerts are inherently irritating and useless, but this one was especially irksome because it would not go away. I had to quit Firefox to get it to stop.

First off, this script does not protect your intellectual property at all. Anyone can view the page source and save the image, turn off JavaScript, get the image from the page info, or take a screenshot of the page. Second, it hampers customers' harmless browsing habits, and in my case, it forcibly ended my web browsing session. I am looking to purchase high-quality sofas for my soon-to-be-renovated living room, but I will not return to omgBALEETEDurl. There are many other furniture sites that do not interfere with a basic functionality of my user interface, let alone force me to close my browser if I happen to click the wrong button.

Please consider removing this script. A much more practical way to protect your images would be to visibly watermark them so no one could pass them off as their own work. Thank you for your time.
 
 
Current Mood: grumpygrumpy
 
 
 
Tommytommathy on April 18th, 2006 06:26 am (UTC)
Yeah, give'em hell, Rydain!

On a tangentially related note (the tangent point being, urr, one definitely correct person, one stupid person, and an e-mail)

http://www.centos.org/modules/news/article.php?storyid=127
The Heavy Metal Matador: South Park - Happyrydain on April 18th, 2006 09:26 pm (UTC)
HA! Comedy gold! I'll forward that along to my office mates.
yuda on April 18th, 2006 02:24 pm (UTC)
Hell yeah!
Ungrateful Ninjauninja on April 18th, 2006 06:25 pm (UTC)
I hate those click traps. My predecessor here used them in all his web applications...grrrr...

In Firefox if you go to Settings...Content...then the Advanced... button next to JavaScript there's an option to control if scripts can "Disable or replace context menus" which helps thwart most of these evil JavaScripts (or at least the ones that had annoyed me in older versions of Mozilla/Firefox).

I wish content creators would get over the notion that they can control exactly how people will experience their creations and get back to making good content instead of expending so much effort producing crappy DRM that only serves to annoy their audience/customers.